Part 1
Chapter 1 — The Red Boxes
“Don’t start this again, Mom.”
Ben’s voice cut across the table before Lauren could answer.
Nancy froze with the serving spoon halfway above the potatoes.
“I asked a simple question.”
“No, you didn’t.”
Lauren touched Ben’s wrist under the table.
“Ben.”
He looked at her.
She gave him the small, controlled smile he knew too well.
Nancy set the spoon down.
“I was asking whether Lauren plans to spend every Christmas here forever.”
Lauren’s fingers tightened around her napkin.
“We’ve spent every Christmas Eve here since we got married.”
“Exactly.”
The word landed harder than Nancy seemed to intend.
Ben leaned back.
“And we’ve been married six years.”
“I know how long you’ve been married.”
“Then what are we discussing?”
Nancy reached for her wine.
Across from them, Ben’s sister, Emily, suddenly became interested in cutting her turkey.
Mark kept his eyes on his plate.
Lauren felt everyone doing the same thing.
Avoiding her.
Avoiding Nancy.
Ben’s father, Robert, watched his wife for several seconds.
Then he looked at Lauren.
Not apologetically.
More like he was waiting for something.
Lauren lowered her voice.
“Nancy, if you want Ben and me to spend Christmas somewhere else next year, just say that.”
Robert’s fork stopped.
Nancy stared at Lauren.
“I never said that.”
“You didn’t have to.”
“Lauren.”
Nancy’s smile appeared quickly.
Too quickly.
“You take things personally.”
Ben pushed his chair back an inch.
“She’s my wife. Of course she takes this personally.”
Robert cleared his throat.
Nancy glanced toward him.
It was brief, but Lauren caught it.
Robert looked down again.
Nobody spoke.
Then Emily lifted her glass.
“Can we please not turn Christmas Eve into a family trial?”
Mark gave a nervous laugh.
Ben didn’t.
Lauren slowly withdrew her hand from his wrist.
“Emily’s right.”
Nancy picked up the serving spoon again.
“Good.”
Ben stared at his mother.
Lauren could feel the argument still sitting between them.
Untouched.
And Robert still hadn’t looked at Nancy again.
“You still keep my height marks on that door?”
Ben stopped beside the kitchen doorway.
Lauren looked over.
Faint pencil lines climbed the wood trim beside him.
Nancy carried dishes toward the sink.
“Your father refuses to let me paint over them.”
Robert took two plates from Lauren.
“Some things shouldn’t be erased.”
Nancy turned sharply.
“It’s a doorframe, Robert.”
He held her gaze.
“I know what it is.”
Lauren looked between them.
Ben touched one of the faded marks.
“Christmas Eve, same house, same doorframe.”
“Same arguments,” Emily called from the dining room.
Mark laughed.
This time Ben did too.
The tension eased by a fraction.
Lauren carried another plate toward Robert.
“You really kept all this?”
“Most of it.”
Robert stacked the dishes carefully.
“This house has paperwork older than Ben.”
Nancy opened the dishwasher harder than necessary.
“Nobody wants to hear about paperwork tonight.”
Robert’s eyes moved toward her.
“I wasn’t talking to you.”
The room went quiet again.
Lauren stopped beside the counter.
Robert took the plate from her hand.
For a moment, he seemed ready to say something else.
Nancy stepped between them with a bowl.
“Lauren, could you take the coffee into the living room?”
“Sure.”
Lauren reached for the tray.
Robert spoke behind her.
“Have you ever been up to the cabin in winter?”
Lauren turned.
“Not in winter. Only once in summer.”
Nancy closed the dishwasher.
“She didn’t like the drive.”
“I never said that.”
Nancy’s smile returned.
“You were nervous the entire way.”
“The road was narrow.”
Robert watched Lauren.
“But you liked the cabin?”
“I loved it.”
His expression softened.
“I thought you might.”
Nancy stared at him.
Lauren noticed.
So did Ben.
“What does that mean?” Ben asked.
Robert picked up a dish towel.
“Nothing.”
Nancy immediately added, “Exactly.”
Lauren carried the coffee away.
Behind her, no one resumed talking.
“Everybody back to the table.”
Nancy entered carrying a stack of small red boxes.
Emily’s face brightened.
“Oh, you actually did gifts tonight?”
“These aren’t exactly gifts.”
Nancy placed one box in front of Emily.
Another went to Mark.
Then Ben.
Lauren watched the boxes move around the table.
Each was identical.
Red paper.
White ribbon.
Small enough to fit in one hand.
Robert remained near the doorway.
He wasn’t carrying a box.
Ben looked at his.
“What is this?”
“Open it.”
Emily pulled at her ribbon first.
Nancy stopped her.
“Wait until everyone has one.”
She picked up another box.
Lauren shifted her coffee cup aside.
Nancy’s hand paused.
Only for a second.
Then she placed the box in front of Lauren.
Their eyes met.
“Merry Christmas.”
Lauren touched the ribbon.
“Thank you.”
Robert’s jaw tightened.
Nancy returned to her chair.
Mark turned his box over.
“This feels like jewelry.”
“You wish,” Emily said.
Ben shook his box beside his ear.
Nancy slapped the tabletop lightly.
“Don’t do that.”
Ben grinned.
“What, is it fragile?”
“No.”
Nancy folded her hands.
“Just open them properly.”
Lauren looked toward Robert.
He had moved closer now.
One hand rested against the back of an empty chair.
His knuckles were pale.
“Dad?” Ben said. “You know what these are?”
Robert looked at Nancy before answering.
“I know what they’re supposed to be.”
Nancy’s head turned.
Lauren caught the change in her face.
The smile remained.
Her eyes didn’t.
“Robert.”
“What?”
“Sit down.”
He didn’t.
Emily looked between them.
“Okay, now this feels weird.”
Nancy ignored her.
She looked at Lauren’s box.
Then back at Robert.
“Everyone open them.”
Lauren slipped one finger beneath the ribbon.
Robert’s grip tightened against the chair.
And Nancy watched Lauren instead of anyone else.
Emily opened her box first.
A small brass key rested inside.
She gasped.
“No way.”
Ben lifted his lid.
Another key.
Mark stared into his own box.
“You’re kidding.”
Nancy finally relaxed against her chair.
“The cabin.”
Emily picked up the key.
“You made copies?”
“For everyone.”
Mark held his between two fingers.
“Even me?”
Nancy smiled at him.
“Of course you.”
Lauren’s hand stopped on her ribbon.
Ben turned his key over.
A small wooden tag had been attached to it.
CABIN.
He looked genuinely surprised.
“Mom, you never let anyone have copies.”
“I changed my mind.”
Emily laughed.
“This means we don’t have to call you every time we want to go?”
“That’s the idea.”
Mark leaned toward her.
“I’ve officially made it.”
Emily bumped his shoulder.
“Six years and you finally get cabin privileges.”
Lauren’s eyes flicked toward Ben.
Six years.
The same length of time she had been married to him.
Ben noticed too.
His smile faded slightly.
Robert moved around the table.
He stopped behind Lauren’s chair.
Nancy watched him.
“Robert, sit down.”
“I’m fine.”
“You’re hovering.”
“I said I’m fine.”
Lauren glanced up at him.
His attention wasn’t on the keys.
It was on her unopened box.
She gave him a questioning look.
Robert opened his mouth.
Nancy spoke first.
“Lauren.”
Lauren looked across the table.
Nancy nodded toward the box.
“Aren’t you going to open yours?”
Ben rested his hand beside Lauren’s.
“Come on.”
Lauren pulled the ribbon loose.
The knot slid apart.
Robert stepped back.
His face had gone still.
Lauren lifted the lid only an inch.
Nancy didn’t blink.
And suddenly Lauren understood that everyone else had been watching their keys.
Nancy had been watching her.
No comments yet — be the first.
